Understanding Plagiarism to Avoid Controversy
The 2016 Republican National Convention in Cleveland, Ohio, whether for good or bad, seemed poised to grab quite a few headlines and to stir controversy while it happened. Surprisingly, one particular controversy touched upon a subject that is quite close to what we do: the question of whether Melania Trump’s speech on Monday, July 18th, plagiarized an address Michelle Obama made to the Democratic National Convention in 2008.
So, did she?
Guest blog article by Jennifer Haber
Probably the most frustrating part of being a writing instructor is that although I give students feedback and feedback and more feedback, I sometimes wonder if they ever read it. In fact, I remember a few semesters ago when for the third time I wrote on a student’s paper, “Remember, you don’t begin a paragraph with a quote; you need to present an idea first and then support it with the evidence.” Maybe she didn’t understand what I meant, I thought.
Finally, after our next class, I asked to speak with her. “Tiffany,” I probed. “Do you know what I meant by that comment I placed on your paper?”
“What comment?” she asked. “Oh, I don’t really look at those.”
Your students are actually always thinking about voice and audience -- they just may not be aware of it! One way to teach rhetorical analysis is to have students analyze their own texts and tweets for audience, tone, and voice.
For most people, the word “story” is a simple noun used to describe the plot or narrative of a work. However, for Adam Tramantano, story is also a verb, one used to describe the process of writing and the point of view of the author.
Tramantano, an English teacher at the Bronx High School of Science, is also a doctoral student in English Education and an adjunct instructor at Teacher’s College, Columbia University. He recently sat down with Jason Chu for a webcast entitled “What’s the Story Behind Why We Write?” that delved into how we can make writing a more conscious and deliberate process for students.
When it comes to giving feedback, instructors often struggle to find ways to communicate to students what they need to do to improve their writing.
To many educators, there’s a belief that students in eastern countries learn through rote memorization and copying while those in western countries focus more or original work and creative thought.
Though the stereotype is obviously not the complete truth, there are cultural differences between educational approaches in countries with an eastern cultural background and those with a western approach.
When it comes to giving feedback to students, educators often wonder how much their work is sinking in.
by Jennifer Haber, Professor of Communications at St. Petersburg College
When I first found out about Turnitin years ago, I used it strictly as a way to check students’ writings for plagiarism. It would give me an originality percentage, and I was able to identify if students had used sources and cited correctly. But, two years, I realized that Turnitin was much more powerful than I had originally thought, and I began using it in different ways. In fact, Turnitin became a means of providing feedback and having students work through writing as a process.
For educators, one of the biggest challenges trying to teach students how to create truly original work and to think for themselves.
This can be difficult because so much of education involves learning, processing and repeating what others have created before. Whether it’s interpreting literature, understanding scientific principles or remembering key individuals in history, students are expected to expand their knowledge, not break new ground.
Ah, the summer! As students shift into their summer experiences, challenge them to keep growing and learning. This month’s prompt ideas focus on learning in unexpected ways—particularly from unexpected people.
- Teaching With Technology: Empowering Students to Take Control of Their Own Learning
- Turnitin Marks Global Accessibility Awareness Day
- Promptastic: Discovery and Reflection in Student Writing
- How Not to Teach Writing: Literary Playdough, Six Points of Soul, and Assessments That Make Me Queasy
- Promptastic: Promoting More Thoughtful and Polished Drafts
- 8 Webcasts to Help Students Write Better | Writing X Tech 2016
- Turnitin Support Wizard and Onboarding Resources
- Finding Integrity Beyond Integrity
- Four Tips to Transform Your Students' Writing—and How You Assess It
- 6 Exclusive AP® Exam Prompts Added to Revision Assistant